Discounts For Honest Amazon Reviews Is Fine; Paying For Bogus Reviews Isn’t

Amazon Reviews Legalities
UPDATE: Amazon recently changed its policy; sellers can no longer offer discounts in exchange for reviews (in most circumstances). We decided to keep this article up for archival purposes.

Team members from BestReviews analyzed 360,000 consumer posts on Amazon.com. Their conclusion? Amazon is flooded with 4- and 5-star reviews, which raised the question: “Can Amazon reviews be trusted?” The answer: Yes, but be aware.

The team observed that:

  • 66.3% of Amazon user ratings are 4- or 5-stars;
  • A “verified purchase” doesn’t mean “full price purchase;”
  • 96% of people who got a free or deeply discounted product gave 4- or 5-star assessments, even though they weren’t required to post high-ratings, just honest ratings.

Can You Trust Amazon Reviews?

So, what does this all mean? Does it illustrate a flaw in Amazon’s review system? Are Amazon reviews worthless?

No, it’s not that drastic.

What the results DO prove is that recipients of free and discounted goods are more likely to give a positive rating than people who pay full price. Humans emotionally connect to money because it’s associated with survival. As such, the more dollars we part with for a product, the more likely we’ll be critical of its shortcomings.
What the results DO prove is that recipients of free and discounted goods are more likely to give a positive rating than people who pay full price.

How Algorithms Can Affect
Amazon Reviews

To balance the review field, Amazon’s rating algorithm gives more weight to reviews written by people who pay full price than those written by launch reviewers who likely got a free product.

Amazon Doesn’t Care If You Give Away Free Products In Exchange For Honest Reviews

(This policy has since changed.)

You’ve probably seen the words “honest review” in an Amazon post.  That usually means the author got the product for free or at a deep discount.

Yes, it’s against Amazon rules to pay for fake reviews outright. It’s fine, however, to give away free products in exchange for honest reviews.

An Amazon spokesperson explained that the company “does not allow compensation or incentive for reviews” except “when sellers provide a [free or discounted] copy of the product, in advance, in exchange for an unbiased review.”

Yes, it’s against Amazon rules to pay for fake reviews outright. It’s fine, however, to give away free products in exchange for honest reviews.

Amazon Explains Why It Loves User Reviews

When communicating with the BestReviews team, Amazon expressed its love of consumer feedback, explaining:

“We believe that all reviews, positive and negative, help customers make informed purchasing decisions. The fact that customers received the product at a deep discount or for free does not preclude them from having an opinion on the product that can be helpful to other customers. Customers indicate that the content of many of these reviews are incredibly helpful. These reviews often provide additional factual information, videos and photos of the actual product in use, and the reviewers often answer follow-up questions.”

Got Review Issues? We Can Help.

We’re review physicians who revive businesses hobbled by damaging feedback. How do we do it? Well, strategies are detail specific, and everyone’s case is different. Let’s talk about your situation and develop a plan that will get you back on track.

Article Sources

Agarwal, Kriti, and Rafe Needleman. “Can You Trust Reviews on Amazon?” Can You Trust Reviews on Amazon? 14 Mar. 2016. Web. 25 Apr. 2016. <https://www.yahoo.com/tech/can-you-trust-reviews-on-amazon-174800847.html>.

Yes! I Want To Talk To An Attorney About An Online Review Issue »